our brokers review of dufferin mutual insurance

☏ 1.855.385.4226
get a quote
book a chat
CSR Melissa C
Meet Melissa Cohoe one of our A+ Brokers from the Dream Team! Her ratings on Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company are all here and if you ever need to know more about these partners, your rates and coverages be sure to give Melissa a call!

Watch Melissa's review of Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company.

Our Broker Ratings:

Overall Service

Product Offering

4 Stars

Response Times

4 Stars

Premiums and Rates

4 Stars

Overall Claim Service

4 Stars

About Dufferin

Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company was founded in 1895 as a farm mutual and remains a true ‘mutual’ today, owned entirely by its policyholders. The headquarters are still in Shelburne, in the heart of the district it serves.

They are a fully licensed multi-line insurer offering property, automobile, and liability insurance protection to over 5000 policyholders. However, what has not changed is that they operate in your area – and are your local insurer. As a corporate citizen for over 100 years, they continue to support the communities in which they work and conduct business in.

Dufferin Mutual markets insurance through independent brokers who operate throughout South Central Ontario.

Products Offered:

  • Home Insurance
  • Car Insurance
  • Commercial Insurance
  • Farm Insurance

The Duliban Hometown Advantage

We Work For You

Our team of insurance professionals ensures that YOU receive the best coverage possible at the very best price.


We partner with over 25 different insurance companies that fight to earn your business.

Highly Rated

With multiple provincial and national recognition awards, it’s no wonder why our clients rave about us.

Simple Language

We make sure that you understand your policy without confusing you with complicated insurance jargon.

Let's find you the best possible coverage